I'm not talking about Simon's popularity, Asaph. Which is
what you seem to be describing. Simon is well known and
well respected by his peers and fans alike and deservedly so.
Again, I still don't think he gets the recognition he deserves.
But I cannot put him in the same catagory as a Billy and some
others I've named. His musical pallet's just not wide enough.
Even Virgil, He does some amazing things behind the kit but
he hasn't really been sought after by the established legendary
players. Simon actually has to some degree but he's seemed to
have hit the proverbial brick wall when it come to "great drummers
we look to when it comes to drumming inspiration. You just don't
see his name that much....
I really like Simon but what you said earlier carries a lot of weight I
believe. He does what he does very well, but again, once you've
heard him, you've heard him... I don't mean that as a dis. That's
just the way it is. For me, Simon Phillips is a guy with great control
and ability. He has the best dexterity from either side than any
drummer I've ever seen and I thorougly enjoy watcing him work.
However, that "WOW" factor was never there for me when it
comes to him.
Whether or not that makes him less great is debatable. In my view
there's just something about what he says behind the drums that
just doesn't move me like that. Yet, I find him more than interesting
to listen to.... Go figure. Hence, the enigma.